The issue of determining the greatest golfer of all time is arguably one of the biggest debates in the sports industry. For decades, fans, historians, and analysts have debated and disputed this topic. Yet, there is no clear answer since there are too many variables: different eras of golf, equipment advancements, level of competitiveness, and the changing demographics of the athlete population.

To clearly answer the question of who is the best golfer, you can’t just tally up the wins. Instead, you need to evaluate several factors like statistics, impact, longevity, and accomplishments. In this article, we will discuss all the important factors and tell you what makes the best golfer.

Defining the “Best Golfer of All Time”

Besides the statistics and criteria, some players use analytical tools when comparing golfers across different eras. This is very similar to how gamblers compare online casinos to find the one they like. For example, when evaluating a list of online casinos, some people break down the platform's license, security, games, bonuses, and payout options to find the best brand for their gaming. Likewise, golf historians compare golfers from previous generations via measurable strength, consistency, and performance. 

Here are some general criteria golf experts use to compare golfers:

• Major championships. These are considered the ultimate achievement and represent the main factor when measuring a player's legacy. 
• Total PGA tour wins. If a player has consistently won major championships, this indicates the ability to compete effectively no matter the tournament conditions and settings.
• The player’s longevity. Some players enjoy success early in their careers but slow down later. Others continue to display their skills for long periods of time. 
• The impact on the game. How influential are they to golf? Did they expand golf's influence globally?
• Strength of competition in their generation. The caliber of competitors changes by generation. So, comparing the quality of competition of the past and present is very difficult. 

The Top Contenders For the Best Golfer of All Time

Before we say who's the best golfer, we need to review all the top candidates. 

Tiger Woods
Tiger Woods dominated golf unlike any other athlete. During his peak golfing period (late 1990s to mid-2000s), he established a new standard for excellence in golf. Woods has won 82 PGA tournaments and won 15 Major Championships. He also set a competitive edge on the course and forever altered the way players prepare and train physically and mentally for their games. 

Jack Nicklaus
Jack Nicklaus, or “the Golden Bear,” owns the record for 18 Major Championships won. Across many decades, he was consistently able to put pressure when it counted the most. His longevity, consistency, and mental toughness set the bar for the remainder of his generation of golfers.

Arnold Palmer
Arnold Palmer’s enduring legacy transcends golf. He brought excitement to the court and to the television audiences watching the game. His bold and aggressive style of play made him an instant fan-favorite. He played a pivotal role when it came to golf’ television popularity.

Ben Hogan
After being injured in a serious car accident, Ben Hogan showed incredible will and perseverance when he returned to the sport. After his return, he won 6 additional Major Championship titles, and is widely regarded as one of the best strikers. 

Bobby Jones
Bobby is regarded as the best amateur golfer in the history of the game. He completed the original Grand Slam in 1930 by winning all 4 Major Championship titles. Additionally, he helped create the Augusta National Golf Club and the Masters Tournament.

Modern Contenders: Can Anyone Surpass the Legends?

There is a limited number of modern players who can actually compete with these legendary players mentioned above. The only ones that scratch the surface are Rory McIlroy, Jon Rahm, and Scottie Scheffler. But, to even join the conversation of who is the best golfer ever, they will need to win multiple Majors and be a dominant force in golf for a long time.
Due to the highly competitive environment, the journey to achieving the status of the GOAT is steeper than ever. 

Public Perception

While the majority of golf enthusiasts disagree on the best golfer in the world, most fans base their opinions on their individual preferences. Many fans like the Tiger Woods peak dominance, while others prefer the longevity of Jack Nicklaus.
Typically, fans form their opinions on charisma, memorable performances, and the time period when they first watched that golfer. Media coverage and highlights of golfers’ performances have a big influence on public perception. 

Conclusion

Each of the legends covered in this article achieved greatness in their unique fashion. Tiger Woods redefined a golfer’s peak performance and global appeal. Jack Nicklaus holds the record for winning the most Major Championships. Ben Hogan, Arnold Palmer, and Bobby Jones all established the precedent for modern-day golf.
Ultimately, the debate on the best golfer today is between Tiger and Jack. But maybe the best part of this aspect of golf is that this debate will continue to rage even for future generations.